Donnelly Street runs through the Beaty neighbourhood in north Milton, a quiet residential corridor framed by newer subdivisions and open green space.
Donnelly Street runs through the Beaty neighbourhood in north Milton, a quiet residential corridor framed by newer subdivisions and open green space. The street sits east of Regional Road 25, within walking distance of several elementary schools and a short drive from Highway 401. Its layout is straightforward: a single through road with no directional split, lined with detached homes and a handful of semis. The surrounding area is defined by family-oriented development, with parks and playgrounds scattered throughout. Donnelly Street feels settled without being old, a product of Milton's early 2000s expansion into the northern reaches of town.
The housing stock on Donnelly Street consists primarily of detached homes, with a single semi-detached property among the recent transactions. Most homes were built in the early 2000s by Mattamy Homes, a builder with a strong presence in this part of Milton. The typical detached home offers four bedrooms, two and a half bathrooms, and a double-car garage. Lot sizes are generous for a suburban street, with frontages around 40 feet and depths extending to 110 feet. The architecture leans toward traditional two-storey designs with brick and vinyl exteriors, pitched roofs, and attached garages.
Inside, the floor plans follow a familiar pattern: a main floor with a combined living and dining area, a family room off the kitchen, and a powder room near the entrance. Upstairs, the master bedroom includes a walk-in closet and ensuite bath. Many homes on Donnelly Street have been updated with hardwood flooring, upgraded kitchens, and finished basements. The condition across the street is consistently well maintained, with few signs of deferred upkeep. Exterior treatments vary slightly, with some homes featuring stone accents or bay windows, but the overall aesthetic remains cohesive. The street's uniformity in era and builder gives it a predictable, orderly feel.
Donnelly Street is within a five-minute walk of Irma Coulson Public School, making it a practical choice for families with elementary-aged children. Several other schools, including Robert Baldwin and Sam Sherratt, are within a ten-minute walk. Coates Park is a five-minute drive away, offering sports fields and a playground. For groceries, Walmart and FreshCo are both a four-minute drive south on Regional Road 25. Milton District Hospital is five minutes by car, and Highway 401 is accessible in about four minutes via the Regional Road 25 interchange.
The Milton GO Station is a 16-minute drive, which shapes the commute for those working in Toronto. The drive downtown takes just over an hour by GO train and TTC. For daily errands, the nearby plaza at Thompson Road and Derry Road includes a pharmacy, a bank, and several quick-service restaurants. The Milton Muslim Community Centre is a four-minute drive, and several other places of worship are within ten minutes. The street's location in north Milton places it close to the escarpment, with Kelso Conservation Area a nine-minute drive for hiking and skiing in season.
Donnelly Street trades infrequently, with only a handful of transactions over the past year. The typical detached home has moved around $1.1M, though the range has been uneven across quarters. In Q3 2024, trades clustered near $1.17M, then eased slightly to $1.17M in Q3 2025, before settling around $1.02M in Q2 2026. The street's two active listings suggest supply is tight, and days on market average around 85, indicating a measured pace. Lease activity is limited: a two-bedroom unit rented near $1,400 per month and a four-bedroom near $3,500, implying gross yields in the low single digits against typical sale prices. The street's character in Beaty draws families seeking newer detached homes near parks and schools, with a quiet suburban feel that compensates for the thin trade record.
Across 1023 - BE Beaty, comparable detached homes have sold at broadly similar levels. The typical sold price sits around $1.14M, based on a substantial sample of recent trades. Year over year, prices have softened modestly, easing by roughly 4%. Buyers have generally paid at or slightly above asking, with the sold-to-ask ratio near 1.01, reflecting a market where well-priced homes attract competitive offers. Neighbourhood-wide days on market average around 82, closely matching the street's own pace.
Donnelly Street sits in the Beaty neighbourhood, a position that puts the 401 on-ramp at Regional Road 25 just four minutes away. That makes Mississauga a 22-minute drive and Pearson reachable in just over half an hour. The Milton GO Station is a 16-minute drive, which for Toronto commuters means a total trip of about 64 minutes door-to-door. The street itself is quiet, with no through-traffic to speak of, so the road network handles the daily flow without noise.
Public elementary students on Donnelly Street draw to Irma Coulson Public School, a one-minute drive that makes it a practical walk for families. Robert Baldwin Public School and Sam Sherratt Public School are each about five minutes away, offering catchment alternatives. Catholic elementary students attend Our Lady of Fatima Catholic Elementary School, a six-minute drive, while secondary students route to St. Francis Xavier Catholic Secondary School, also six minutes away. The public secondary catchment draws to Craig Kielburger Secondary School, the dominant option for this part of Beaty.
Donnelly Street tends to suit families looking for a newer, quiet pocket in Beaty with quick highway access. The detached and semi-detached homes, built in the early 2000s, appeal to buyers who want a finished neighbourhood with established landscaping and mature trees. The tradeoff is that the GO station is a 16-minute drive, so households where one or both partners commute downtown will need a car for the station run. Renters here are typically long-term anchored families, with unfurnished leases and a 12-month term being the norm. The street suits those who value a calm setting and highway proximity over walkable transit.
If walkability to the GO station matters more, buyers might consider streets closer to the Milton GO Station, where the tradeoff is often tighter lots and older stock. For those prioritizing lower entry prices, the condo market on Martin Street trades around $310,000, a different product type and ownership structure. If a larger lot or more square footage is the goal, homes built in the 1990s in the established parts of Beaty offer more generous frontages, though the interiors may need updating. Each alternative shifts the balance between price, space, and commute convenience.
Detached inventory on Donnelly Street has seen 4 closed sales recently. Details below.
Semi inventory on Donnelly Street has seen 1 closed sales recently. Details below.
Sale activity on Donnelly Street in the recent period. Stats reflect closed transactions only.
Rental activity on Donnelly Street across recent months. Breakdown by bed count below.
| Date | Address | Beds | Sold | vs Ask | DOM | Listing brokerage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loading sold records… | ||||||
A thoughtful conversation grounded in every sale we have tracked on Donnelly Street.
Request a valuation →